发信人: mechania (sweet), 信区: SJTU
标 题: true color of JTU history by XJTU alumni
发信站: The unknown SPACE (Tue Dec 29 21:07:09 1998), 转信
call for help to return the true color of JTU history
[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ 交通大学国际论坛 ]
Posted by XJTU alumni on December 27, 1998 at 06:58:57:
I salute sandford's effort, and appreciate his knowledgeable writing. However,
upon reading the article, it seem to me that 40% stayed in shanghai and 60%
relocated to xi'an.
I have following puzzles,
1. Did old JTU have 24+19 specializations? among them 24 relocated to xi'an
and 19 stayed in shanghai? It is very weird that SJTU can be called as an
engineering oriented university without ME and EE. Therefore those 19
specializations must include some new department, like ME and EE, that were
founded in a very short time. In another word, those 24 are real numbers and
represent the power of JTU, 19 is an exaggerated or with very little power.
This is the real reason that XJTU is much stronger in academic and research
2. I would like to know more detail about that 2/3 and 60% ratio. To me, it
is completely new, I doubt one or both of XJTU and SJTU have hidden some
facts in the JTU histroy. Therefore, both XJTU and SJTU alumni should do
some research to return the true color of this incident.
Before sandford bringing the very sensitive topic
'which is real or inheritage of JTU', I strongly suggest we, both XJTU and
SJTU alumni have the relocation part properly settled, which is based on
facts not on opinions. I also hope, which is extremly difficult, to have
something conclusive about JTU histroy and stop the debut or even fight
between xjtu and sjtu alumni.
I call for the efforts from both sides, especially those still in school, go
to library and bring in more detailed information about JTU history from
56-59. In the flow chart of JTU histroy in XJ, it is clearly marked as
'majority part of JTU relocated to xi'an' while in sj home page or bbs, the
same flow chart is different only in this remark 'part of jtu relocated to
xi'an', such a tiny difference reflects a very big problem in treating JTU
histroy at univerity official level. we must solve this problem first, like,
'remembering the past is the basis for facing the future' If one or both
XJTU and SJTU teach their students using different versions of history,
reunite of JTU can never happen!
Let us put more numbers and facts on this board and return the true color of
this relocation or spliting incident. quote from original document not from
opinion is highly appreciated.
※ 来源:．The unknown SPACE bbs.mit.edu．[FROM: 184.108.40.206]